Phillies Hot Stove: Club Interested in Mets Closer Familia
Stark: Executives, Scouts Believe Phillies Are 'Favorite' to Acquire Machado

Phillies Roundtable: Potential Trade Targets to Bolster Club for Postseason Run

With the non-waiver trade deadline almost two weeks away, speculation continues to intensify regarding who general manager Matt Klentak and the Philadelphia Phillies will acquire to bolster their postseason-contending roster.

In the latest edition of "Phillies Roundtable," writers Jesse Larch, Matt Albertson, Matt Noskow and Paul Bowman speculate potential trade targets the Phillies could consider this July.

Jesse Larch: Blake Snell, Matt Duffy

Not only is Blake Snell currently the ERA leader in the American League, but he is a 25-year old left handed pitcher who makes a little over $500,000 in salary and is under team control through 2022. The Phillies currently have no lefties in their starting rotation, and have been rumored to be keen on adding a southpaw to their stable of starters. Names of former Phillies like J.A. Happ and Cole Hamels have dominated the rumor mill but Blake Snell is one of the best lefties in all of baseball this season, and is possibly still not in his prime. Being able to add the lefty Snell to juxtapose the right-handed Aaron Nola at the top of the Phillies rotation would be a move that could give the Phillies a real shot at National League dominance bearing in mind that the team would maintain their financial flexibility heading into the offseason with this move.
Matt Duffy is a nice throw-in in the deal. The Phillies have been connected to multiple infielders, including Royals utility man Whit Merrifield. Duffy is a versatile infielder and bringing his .307 batting average off of the bench would be a welcome addition to a team that has struggled to pinch hit outside of Nick Williams and the recent hot streak of Andrew Knapp
Any deal involving Snell will be costly given his cheap contract, years of control, and success on the field, but forming a one-two punch of Nola and Snell would be worth losing some of the top names in the Phillies' farm system, especially when you factor in that Sixto Sanchez would be waiting in the wings to join Nola and Snell when the pair would be in their prime years. Sending Pivetta and Kilome to Tampa in the deal also immediately opens two spots on the 40-man roster for Snell and Duffy to easily slide into. For a rental like Manny Machado this could be a steep price, but Snell would be coming to Philadelphia for the remainder of this season and the next four at a minimum. While Snell's name does not carry the same weight as Machado's, Snell has certainly validated himself as one of the elite players in the league with his dominance this season. To put Snell's dominance in perspective, consider how great Aaron Nola has been in his 19 starts posting a 2.27 ERA with 126 strikeouts in 123.0 innings pitched. Snell has also started 19 games, but has a lower ERA (2.09), and more strikeouts (132) in less innings (116.0). Putting the two together would bode well for the team's immediate future and the team's long-term outlook as well. 

Matt Albertson: Eduardo Escobar, Brian Dozier

It's clear that the Phillies are looking for infield help and possibly a bench bat. The Twins' Eduardo Escobar might fit the bill as a versatile infielder who has experience at second, short and third. The 29 year old Venezuelan is currently slashing .272/.328/.517 with 14 home runs and 54 RBI. Additionally, he currently leads the majors with 35 doubles. Better yet, he’s slashing .357/.424/.690 with runners in scoring position and .295/.380/.545 RISP with runners in scoring position with two outs. This season, he's played 67 games at third, 21 at short, and one at second. He can platoon with Franco at third and Kingery/Crawford at short. It would also allow Kingery to get time at his natural position at second if Hernandez is traded. (The Twins are likely to trade second baseman Brian Dozier by the non-waiver deadline as well, opening a spot for Hernandez).

Why Escobar? The Twins don't appear to be positioned to return to the postseason this year given their 41-49 record, 8.5 games behind Cleveland. He's a rental too, so he'd probably be cheaper to acquire than a controlled player like Whit Merrifield. Minnesota's starting pitchers rank 13th in ERA (4.32) and 2018 free agent signee Lance Lynn hasn't performed to expectations in a pitcher's park. Trading someone like Cesar Hernandez with a minor league pitcher not named Sixto Sanchez or Adonis Medina might get the Phils into a conversation.

Matt Noskow: Jedd Lowrie, Blake Treinen

The Phillies should look to target two players from the A’s being Jed Lowrie and Blake Treinen.

This would be a perfect move for the Phillies. Lowrie is an All-Star this year and a veteran bat that can give the Phillies reps at third base. Lowrie will likely not solve the defensive woes the Phillies suffer from this year but, his bat production should suffice for that. Adding Lowrie’s bat here would help the Phillies drive in more runs. The Phillies are among the best teams in baseball at drawing walks. Batting Lowrie third or fifth behind either Santana or Hoskins who have some of the best plate discipline on the team could do wonders for the middle of that order.

Treinen would be the bigger piece of this deal. Treinen, is having a fantastic year at the back end of the bullpen and has fantastic stuff (see any of Pitching Ninja gifs on twitter). This year he has a 5-2 record with 23 saves and a .98 ERA with a FIP below 2. Besides his great stats on the season, he is under contract for the next three years and would be relatively cheap. Adding a long-term piece like this could help solidify the backend of the bullpen as well as designate current bullpen piece to better roles.

The Phillies would likely have to give up a package of prospects to get these two. The package wouldn’t be tremendously deep but would likely cost starting pitching such as Enyel De Los Santos. A similar trade to compare this to would be the trade that took place last year between the White Sox and Yankees. The Yankees acquired Todd Frazier, David Robertson, and Tommy Kahnle for a combination of prospects. Look for the A’s to look to acquire starting pitching prospects in any deal from the Phillies.

Paul Bowman: Zach Britton, Jordy Mercer, Asdrubal Cabrera

I’d like to start out by saying that I am not opposed to the Phillies standing pat at the deadline. I think it would be beneficial to get as many of the young guys playoff experience as possible, not to mention the team should be getting back Jerad Eickhoff (career 3.87 ERA) to sure up the back end of the rotation and may yet get Pedro Florimon back, who can play nearly every position and has a .301/.351/.485 slash line since joining the Phillies last year.

That said, the Phillies have too many upper level minor leaguers to protect from the Rule 5 draft next year, so it would make sense to move some of those guys before the farm is pillaged for nothing. Particularly they have a lot of starters to move – they have a full rotation now with Eickhoff and Lively on the DL and De Los Santos, Irvin, Eshelman, and Anderson in Lehigh Valley. I would probably look to move the struggling Eshelman or Anderson along with some lower level prospects not named Sixto Sanchez.

I would turn my attention to Baltimore. If the Orioles price comes down, Manny Machado would obviously be a good pickup, but I think the Phillies should swing a deal for Zach Britton. Britton has converted 137 of 148 save opportunities over the past five seasons and would give the Phillies a true closer. It could also allow them to groom younger players by making someone like Victor Arano the seventh inning guy and Seranthony Dominguez the setup man.

Other than Machado, the Phillies have been connected to a lot of third basemen. The only other player has been Whit Merrifield, who is under team control for four more years and could cost too much. Now, what I am about to say may be a hot take, but I wouldn’t take Maikel Franco out of the lineup. He is second on the team in average (.274), fourth on the team in home runs (12) and fourth in RBIs (45) despite batting in the eighth spot. Even if you plan to trade him, he is increasing his trade value for this offseason. I would look for bench players who could play shortstop – the Phillies least productive position. Among those available are Jordy Mercer of the Pirates and Asdrubal Cabrera of the Mets. Mercer would provide a slight upgrade over Kingery/Crawford slashing .246/.307/.387. Cabrera is on the midst of another productive season, slashing .280/.328/.485 with 16 home runs (one of which was a walk-off to beat the Phillies in Game one of Monday’s double-header) and 51 RBIs. The trick there is that you never want to give the Mets too much that it will come back to bite you.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


Why would the A's give up two of their best players when they're in a playoff race? Makes no sense.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)