Flyers 5: Takeaways from Tuesday’s Flyers-Sabres Game
Two Secondary Effects of the Phillies Offseason That Are Being Severely Overlooked

Phillies: Odd Arm Wins Role for 2021


By Tal Venada, Sports Talk Philly Contributor

While the Philadelphia Phillies faithful celebrate the home run videos of Bryce Harper and others, the difference-making is on the mound. And assuming who the closer-to-be is or isn’t may be neither Archie Bradley nor Hector Neris, plus the battle for the final bullpen seat might be the toughest decision.


Quality Depth:

For the Phillies, one appearance could be a five-way tiebreaker and a ticket to Allentown for second place. Plus an injury-free competition may come down to the final cuts. Furthermore, the victor-to-be must produce to keep his middle-relief role. And he knows it!     


“I try to do the right thing at the right time. They may just be little things, but usually they make the difference between winning and losing.” - Kareem Abdul-Jabbar

Barring the unknown, the Fightins are at or above the $210 million CBT (competitive-balance threshold) because of roster-making contracts, but the players by seriously contending will force the execs to increase payroll for the trading deadline. Therefore, the relief corps is present, but their roles are fluid.               

Dave Dombrowski, president of baseball operations, has assembled proven veterans and some fireballers to compete for up to eight jobs. Though, further investigation reveals the pen is even more striking up close.     

Manager Joe Girardi now has the pieces he needs for the final three innings with the acquisitions of Bradley, Brandon Kintzler and Jose Alvarado to complement Neris. Preferring specific roles, however, Girardi has four potential closers, or he could deploy his best options during critical late-game frames.

With five starters, Tony Watson, David Hale and Vince Velasquez, Girardi could have five other relievers: Bradley, Neris, Kinzler and Alavardo are four. So, Connor Brogdon, Jojo Romero, Sam Coonrod, Hector Rondon and Ranger Suarez will battle for one spot. But Romero and Suarez being portsiders may have an edge.   

Making adjustments is a two-way street for pitchers and hitters. To illustrate, Brogdon’s 16.88 August ERA for three outings dropped to a 0.00 September ERA for six performances, but he did allow an inherited runner to score. And keep in mind, his four-seam fastball averages 95.7 mph with a high of 98.7 mph.   

The league may have adjusted to left-hander Romero after he had recorded a 3.00 ERA for his first seven chances. Unfortunately, he finished his final five opportunities with a 13.50 ERA or headed in the other direction of Brogdon’s 2020. But he has a four-seam heater: 95.8-mph average with a 98-mph high.          

Because these two big arms weren't enough depth for the decision-makers, the Phils signed Coonrod, another flamethrower. But he went from a 3.58 ERA (2019) for 33 outings to a 9.82 ERA (2020) in 18 appearances. Stuff: He averaged 98.7 mph with his four-seam heater and touched 101.6 mph.       

If Rondon makes the red pinstripes, he will earn $1.5 million and increase the CBT over the $210 million AAV (average annual value). However, this could work against him if no injuries open up a back-end role in the bullpen. Plus he struggled in ‘20, but was it just the disruptions? 

Potential Phillies Setup Man:

Hector Rondon, 33: 

  • 2019: 62 Gms., 60 ⅔ Inn., a 3.71 ERA, 19 Holds and a -0.3 fWAR.
  • 2020: 24 Gms., 20 Inn., a 7.65 ERA, 7 Holds and a -0.4 fWAR.
  • 2020: Four-seam Fastball high of 98.1 mph and average of 95.8 mph.
  • 2020: Four-seam Fastball at 49%, Slider at 36.9%, Sinker at 10.3% and Changeup at 3.9%. 

Since the Phillies reported Suarez’s visa issues on Feb. 19, no new information is available on his arrival in Clearwater. Where is he? Remember, he only had two outings last summer: Both were disastrous. Hopefully, he’ll join the squad and return to 2019’s form: a 3.14 ERA for 37 performances.   

While those five moundsmen vie for one spot, many writers have Bradley challenging Neris for the ninth-inning role, but two other relievers have a decent shot as well: Kintzler and Alvarado. And Girardi could employ Neris and Bradley in crucial frames before the ninth.       

Developing a slider as a third pitch could make Neris the go-to weapon for the skipper. But does the right-hander have enough time to twirl a decent one? For now, though, he already has a 94.3-mph four-seam fastball and an extremely late-breaking splitter.   

Potential Phillies Closer: 

Archie Bradley, 28.5:

  • 2019: 66 Gms., 71 ⅔ Inn., a 3.52 ERA, 18 Saves, 7 Holds and a 1.2 fWAR.
  • 2020: 16 Gms., 18 ⅓ Inn., a 2.95 ERA, 6 Saves, 2 Holds and a 0.6 fWAR.
  • 2020: Four-seam Fastball high of 96.4 mph and average of 94.4 mph.
  • 2020: Four-seam Fastball at 56.5%, Curveball at 22.5%, Sinker at 11.6% and Changeup at 9.4%.

Fanwise, Bradley is already the closer, and he has experience retiring the final hitters. But he also has handled late-inning situations, and contests decided in the seventh and eighth frames against the opponent’s best hitters may require Bradley to hold a lead.     

Even though Kintzler could be the seventh-inning reliever, he could also close out less-stressful ninth frames. Last year, Girardi went to Neris for the toughest outs and Brandon Workman for the ninth. Translation: He can use the pen like he did for the New York Yankees or 2020.   

Potential Phillies Closers:

Brandon Kintzler, 36.5: 

  • 2019: 62 Gms., 57 Inn., a 2.68 ERA, 17 Holds, 1 Save and a 0.8 fWAR.
  • 2020: 24 Gms., 24 ⅓ Inn., a 2.22 ERA, 1 Hold, 12 Saves and a -0.2 fWAR.
  • 2020: Sinker high of 93.9 mph and average of 91.7 mph.
  • 2020: Sinker at 71.4%, Changeup at 13.1% and Slider at 10%.  

Jose Alvarado, 25.5: 

  • 2018: 70 Gms., 64 Inn., a 2.39 ERA, 8 Saves, 32 Holds, 80 SO, 33 BB (4 IBB) and a 2.1 fWAR.
  • 2018: Sinker high of 101.1 mph and average of 98 mph.
  • 2018: Sinker at 57.3%, Slider at 18.1%, Four-seam Fastball at 13.1% and Curveball at 11.9%.

With Watson as a lefty setup man, Alvarado could give the manager a closer who can face the heart of the opponent’s batting order. And he could allow Girardi to rely on Bradley and Neris for the most challenging outs before the ninth, so the skipper could gradually move Alvarado into frame nine.    

While Rondon can beat out Brogdon, Romero, Coonrod and Suarez for the last slot in the relief corps, who might claim the closer’s role? Yes, it could be Bradley, Neris or Kintzler in April. But Alvarado has the look of a ninth-inning weapon, so what will he be if it’s his spot in May or June? The odd man in!    



Girardi’s Motivational Plans




Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Old fan

Projected starting lineup
hitting about .120 so far

Tal Venada

Thanks for reading.

For the starting seven, the averages are meaningless. Some guys hit but struggle in April. Others have a so-so spring but crush the ball in April.

Center field is where the production matters to make the team and receive playing time. So, KIngery, Herrera, Quinn, and Moniak are where the stats matter. Moniak probably will open the season at the alternate site and Triple-A in May. Haseley is on the injured list but will push for playing time in April when he's ready.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)